Invest In The Best - By VickiHoefle on September 8, 2009 - 9 Comments
PTA? No Thank You!
It’s that time of year again. Room parent sign ups, volunteering requests, schedules for snacks, PTA elections. AHHHHH. It’s enough to make you want to hide for 12 years. I want to go on record right now as saying that I think schools hire professional recruiters to get parents to say YES, when they have no business saying yes to one more thing.
As parents we have become master jugglers. Family, work, afterschool activities, sports—you name it. Not to mention all of the extras: snack for girl scouts, fundraising for the soccer team, sewing costumes for the drama club . . . It’s never-ending! Feeling the stress of saying yes isn’t the only thing these small extras are costing families.
What’s the cost?
There is a lot of pressure from society today suggesting that “good parents” are involved in their children’s lives; that they say YES to every invitation from every committee, sport team or volunteer program. Here is my beef with the whole “get involved” thinking: Parents are trading activity for being emotionally available to their children. Let’s face it folks, we already know that as good as we are at juggling, eventually, we drop the balls and the first balls dropped are our relationships.
Look, if you are one of those parents who likes to be involved with your child’s school and activities—great! Have at it. Join the PTA, sign up to be Den Mother and bake into the wee hours of the night, if that makes you happy. But if you are beginning to suspect that the trade-off for being an Active Parent vs. an Emotionally Available Parent isn’t worth it, then look that recruiter in the eye, smile sweetly and say NO to their guilt-ridden request. Believe me, there is another sucker standing right behind you who can bake, sell or sew just as good as you.
One of the guiding principles of the Parenting On Track™ program is to “drop” what is not important, what gets in the way of our relationships, what taxes our resources in terms of time, energy and enjoyment and, instead, focus our energy on developing loving, healthy, respectful relationships. Relationships take time—lots of time and lots of energy. But, so do PTA meetings, and sometimes you have to choose.
Here is how I personally resolved this challenge: Don’t ever let anyone at the school see you. Be a mystery for 12 years. You will leave parents, teachers and school administrators curious and leave your children feeling ever so—dare I say—content. Do you know why? Because you are the calm, centered parent who has the resources to sit down and help your child through a difficult homework assignment, a difficult teacher/student relationship, a difficult decision they are struggling with. And because you are content and focused on the relationship, your children learn from you about the really important things in life: Being there for the people you love.
And who really cares if the school doesn’t approve of how you spend your time! Are they in your house each evening, listening in when you have the time to have deep, meaningful conversations with your children about what is going on in their lives and what is important to them, because you said no to the PTA and no to the brownies? I didn’t think so.
9 Comments
Monika
Deb Loomis
I believe there is a balance between saying “no” and “yes.” If we all said no, there would be no PTA, no PTA-sponsored events (winter program, theatre, garden program, etc.), no Little League, no soccer league, no boy scout or girl scout troop, no after-school program, no board of directors for your local preschool or daycare center. If you or your kids benefit from these and other organizations, you may want to find a way to say “yes” once in a while. If we all say “yes” sometimes, our communities are strong and our kids have wonderful opportunities and build lasting relationships with peers and adults outside of the family - which could be very valuable in their teen years.
Emily
Thank you for so clearly articulating something that has been a nagging suspicion of mine. So timely and so true. Thanks for the “permission” to say no for all the right reasons.
Jen Higgins
Oh, Vicki! How I admire thee, let me count the ways…Jen
Maura Slavin
Girl Scouts and PTA enrichment activities and equipment are all well and good, but they don’t compare to having a good relationship between parents and children. It’s good to hear someone say that you can say “No” and not only still be a good parent…but perhaps and even better parent!
Tonia
If only I had this information last year! I’m in the middle of a 2-year treasurer committment meaning I have involvement in just about every PTO thing that happens. Originally, I was glad to have some purpose, but was talking with the bank teller (who I see often!) and she said “purpose has to be personal.” What a great statment! I’ll keep this committment, but it wont be the first thing that gets my attention.
A very good parenting moment: My 5-year-old son ran in from outside before he started swinging and said “Mommy, Anna let me have the swing I wanted, I want to write it on the appreciation board for family meeting!”
Peg R.
This couldn’t have come at a better time (hours before the PTA meeting)… Thank you for helping me over the hurdle of saying “no thank you”
Suzie
THANK YOU for this article! Saying no to all the school related activities requests just got a lot more doable - and for a very good reason… my son! ![]()
Vicki
Thank you all for your responses.
I do understand that there is a balance and I, personally, am so grateful to the many volunteers that keep school, organizations and communities running smoothly.
I also know, that many of us say YES for the wrong reasons.
If volunteering fills your well, if it brings meaning to your life and you still have time for the most important relationships of your life - then for goodness sake - get out there and volunteer.
And to all of us who will make another choice this year - use this time to connect in new and meaningful ways to yourself, your spouse and your kids.
It is these healthy connections that make for a healthy world.
Big love to you all.
Leave a Reply
- The Bullied Child
- Setting an Example
- Bullying: Part I
- The Transition from Frog Collecting to Number Crunching
- Developing Social Interest to Create Healthy Families
- Deborah, I too am experiencing this problem with my kids. I have noticed that m...
- What does one do when they notice this behavior from one of their children to th...
- My son experienced the bullying kid last year at school. To my surprise it was ...
- Bullying is a HUGE topic at my children's elementary school and I take it very s...
- How did I miss this video?! So blubbering. Lovely, Lovely....
- Beautiful, Vicki. Trying to figure out how to print this out so I can put it up ...
- ah, yes. after doing a good 9 mos of PonT, I will admit to still doing a few of...
- Thanks Michele for the correction! We do our best to proof/edit these posts and ...
- Parenting Home Program
Now you can have the entire Parenting On Track™ program on DVD. Benefit from the same parenting strategies and techniques, humor, and support you'd get from attending the six-week course wherever and whenever it's most convenient! - Downloadable Parenting Audio
The perfect complement to the DVD home program, Vicki's insightful interviews on parenting (mp3 format) will help you understand and internalize key Parenting On Track™ principles. - Online Parenting Classes & Web Events
Enroll in a Parenting On Track™ online parenting class or web event. All classes are taught by Vicki Hoefle.
Discovery - 09/02/10 - 0 Comments
The Bullied Child
More In Discovery
- Setting an Example
- Bullying: Part I
- Navigating Summer Expectations
- Its just cake - or is it?
- Shift in Perspective
Invest In The Best - 08/17/10 - 0 Comments
Developing Social Interest to Create Healthy Families
More In Invest In The Best
- Are you raising a bully? Part II
- Summertime and the living is…well, that depends on who you ask
- Kids have Perfect Solutions
- Sibling Appreciation
- Preparing for Departure, the Moment they Arrive

Like always Vicki you have right on target advise and perfect timing!